In Holman v. County of Butte, ordered published August 25, 2021, the Third Appellate District reversed the dismissal of a case on demurrer. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant county, its Health and Human Services Department, and its Sheriff's Office negligently failed to perform mandatory duties related to investigating and reporting allegations of child abuse the plaintiff's parents perpetrated on him in the mid-2000s. The plaintiff alleged repressed childhood memories returned to him in 2017. He filed the lawsuit in 2020. He sued under Government Code section 815.6. The county defendants demurred, argued that the statute of limitations prescribed in Code of Civil Procedure section 338, subdivision (a) governing liability based on statute applied. The statute of limitations is three years. The defendants contended that because other subdivisions of section 338 expressly provide for accrual based on discovery, the discovery standard of accrual does not apply to subdivision (a). The trial court agreed.
The appellate court disagreed. The common law discovery rule is available when section 338, subdivision (a) is the applicable statute of limitations. The courts have applied the discovery rule to other subdivisions of section 338 that do not expressly provide for application of the discovery rule. Absent the Legislature's clear intent, the court presumes the Legislature intended to make the common law discovery rule applicable. The Legislature did not provide that the rule was inapplicable to subdivision (a), nor did it adopt a statute of repose cutting off all liability after a given amount of time no matter the circumstances. The other subdivisions merely provide different triggers of the limitation period than the judicial discovery rule. Further, at least one previous case had applied the discovery rule to subdivision (a). That the plaintiff failed to plead diligence after discovering his cause of action did not affect the timeliness of his complaint, because the plaintiff filed suit within three years of accrual.
Comments